Is Roman Catholicism Right About Tradition? | Dr. W. Robert Godfrey

Dr. W. Robert Godfrey joins Pastor Chris Gordon to examine Rome's appeal to 2 Thessalonians 2:15 and its claim to preserve unwritten apostolic tradition.
Title
Is Roman Catholicism Right About Tradition? | Dr. W. Robert Godfrey
Summary
Dr. W. Robert Godfrey joins Pastor Chris Gordon to examine Rome's appeal to 2 Thessalonians 2:15 and its claim to preserve unwritten apostolic tradition.
Published
Aug 26, 2026
Hosted By
Pastor Chris Gordon
Source
Show Notes

What does the Bible actually mean when Paul tells the Thessalonians to hold fast to the traditions they were taught "either by spoken word or by letter"? Rome has long leaned on that verse to defend a body of unwritten apostolic teaching preserved by the church. In this episode, church historian Dr. W. Robert Godfrey walks through the Greek word behind "tradition" — a plain word meaning to hand over or deliver — and shows how Paul uses the same word group in 1 Corinthians 11 for both the Lord's Supper he delivered to the church and the night Christ was delivered over to be betrayed. Tradition, in its biblical sense, is simply what the apostles taught.

Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction
01:14 - Welcoming Dr. Godfrey
02:06 - Why Study Roman Catholicism
03:38 - Protestant Fatigue and the Draw of Rome
05:23 - Eastern Orthodoxy's Historical Claims
06:36 - The Text: 2 Thessalonians 2:15
07:47 - What "Tradition" Actually Means
10:10 - Rome's Appeal to Oral Tradition
11:51 - The Council of Trent's Answer
15:55 - Vatican I and Papal Infallibility
17:39 - Newman and Doctrinal Development
19:19 - How the Reformers Responded
20:33 - The Mass, Mary, and the Priesthood
23:59 - Is Rome a Place of Rest?
26:04 - Tradition as a "Wax Nose"
27:14 - Grabbing a Greased Pig

Stations

CFJW 92.9 FM
Sundays
Smithers BC, Canada
First Love Radio (Internet)
Monday-Friday @ 7-7:30am
Bagdad, Florida
KARI 550 AM
Monday-Friday @ 2:30-3:00am, 4:30-5:00pm
Blaine, Wa
KGCE-LP 107.9 FM
Monday-Friday @ 7am
Modesto, CA
KKLA
Sundays @ 1-2am, 4-5pm, 7-8pm
Glendale, CA
KPRZ 106.1 FM & 1210 AM
Monday-Friday 5-5:30pm
San Diego, CA
KRDU 1130 AM
Monday-Friday @ 1:30pm
Fresno, CA
WCNP 89.5 FM
Monday-Friday @ 8-8:30am
Reedsburg, Wisconsin

Recent

Video
Nothing But the Truth - 1 Kings 22
Today's sermon presses a single question: do we want what God has actually said, or what we think God should say?
Do vs. Done: The Law/Gospel Distinction with Dr. R. Scott Clark - Part 2
Rev. Chris Gordon and Dr. R. Scott Clark continue their conversation on the distinction between law and gospel, arguing that the issue is not only doctrine but tone. Preach the law in full force, they say, and then send burdened sinners to Christ without conditions.
Partakers of Grace - Phil 1
Paul's affection for the church at Philippi confronts the modern habit of treating the church as a product to consume. The believer's bond to a local congregation rests not on personal preference but on the shared grace of the gospel and the God who finishes what he begins.
Do vs. Done: The Law/Gospel Distinction with Dr. R. Scott Clark
Chris Gordon and Dr. R. Scott Clark respond to a recent critique of law and gospel preaching. They explain what the distinction actually is, where it gets abused, and why abandoning it leaves congregations under the covenant of works.
Whom Shall I Fear?
David's confidence in the Lord is not theory but experience — a life of deliverances read backward. Psalm 27 moves from unshakable joy to raw lament and back to a promise: wait on the Lord, and He will strengthen your heart.
Is Roman Catholicism Right About Tradition? - Part 2
Dr. W. Robert Godfrey joins Pastor Chris Gordon in part 2 of a conversation about "tradition" — from the Bible's own positive use of the word to Rome's claims of an unwritten apostolic deposit — and why every tradition, Protestant or Catholic, must ultimately answer to Scripture.
Newsletter
Our newsletter is a great way to stay up-to-date with all our latest episodes, news, and content and helps us stay in close contact with our listeners.
Subscribe
Like, subscribe and share our podcast on your favorite platform. Be sure to follow us on social media and don't forget to join our newsletter!
Donate
Support The Abounding Grace Radio Ministry
The New Reformation Catechism On Human Sexuality
by Rev. Christopher Gordon

The New Reformation Catechism on Human Sexuality, authored by Rev. Christopher Gordon, is a new biblically based catechism giving clarity on critical issues concerning human sexuality.

"May God bless you richly as you grow in Christian liberty. May this book help you hold fast to the truth and better understand how the full counsel of God speaks to the godly priority of human sexuality."
~ Rosaria Butterfield
Visit Our Store