Is Roman Catholicism Right About Tradition? - Part 2

Dr. W. Robert Godfrey joins Pastor Chris Gordon in part 2 of a conversation about "tradition" — from the Bible's own positive use of the word to Rome's claims of an unwritten apostolic deposit — and why every tradition, Protestant or Catholic, must ultimately answer to Scripture.
Title
Is Roman Catholicism Right About Tradition? - Part 2
Summary
Dr. W. Robert Godfrey joins Pastor Chris Gordon in part 2 of a conversation about "tradition" — from the Bible's own positive use of the word to Rome's claims of an unwritten apostolic deposit — and why every tradition, Protestant or Catholic, must ultimately answer to Scripture.
Published
Sep 2, 2026
Hosted By
Pastor Chris Gordon
Source
Show Notes

How should Reformed Christians think about their own traditions, using the history of Sunday as the Christian Sabbath as a case study in testing inherited practice against the Bible rather than simply defending or discarding it? The episode closes on a hopeful note, reflecting on the substantial doctrinal agreement shared across Bible-believing Protestants and a call to return to patient, expository engagement with Scripture rather than chasing theological controversy.

Chapters:
0:00 - Introduction
1:07 - Oberman's Three Uses of "Tradition"
2:17 - Newman's "Acorn to Oak Tree" and Evolving Tradition
4:09 - Jesus, the Pharisees, and Tradition in Matthew 15
6:31 - Rome's Argument for an Earthly Head of the Church
8:27 - 2 Thessalonians and the Apostolic "Restrainer"
13:39 - Paul's Oral and Written Tradition in 2 Thessalonians 3
15:35 - Dangers of Tradition Among Evangelicals
16:25 - Case Study: Sunday as the Christian Sabbath
20:39 - Jesus' Temptation and the True Appeal to Scripture
22:12 - Common Ground Among Bible-Believing Protestants
24:19 - Closing Thoughts: Tradition, Fatigue, and Returning to the Word

Guest Information:
Dr. W. Robert Godfrey
Chairman of Ligonier Ministries, Professor Emeritus at Westminster Seminary California. He also earned a Master of Arts degree in Historical Theology; his thesis was on Faustus Socinus.
Ligonier Ministries: https://www.ligonier.org

Mentions:
Heiko Oberman, Reformation historian
John Henry Newman, "Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine"
Council of Trent
First Vatican Council
Gerhardus Vos
Huldrych Zwingli and the Marburg Colloquy
Westminster Larger Catechism
Heidelberg Catechism
1 Corinthians 10–11
Matthew 15
Matthew 4:7 / Psalm 91 (temptation of Christ)
2 Thessalonians 1–3
Ephesians 1

Abounding Grace Radio:
❤️ DONATE: https://agradio.org/donate
🔗 Website: https://agradio.org
📩 Newsletter: https://agradio.org/newsletter
👤 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/aboundingraceradioministry
📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/aboundinggraceradio
✖️ X: https://x.com/agradio1

Stations

CFJW 92.9 FM
Sundays
Smithers BC, Canada
First Love Radio (Internet)
Monday-Friday @ 7-7:30am
Bagdad, Florida
KARI 550 AM
Monday-Friday @ 2:30-3:00am, 4:30-5:00pm
Blaine, Wa
KGCE-LP 107.9 FM
Monday-Friday @ 7am
Modesto, CA
KKLA
Sundays @ 1-2am, 4-5pm, 7-8pm
Glendale, CA
KPRZ 106.1 FM & 1210 AM
Monday-Friday 5-5:30pm
San Diego, CA
KRDU 1130 AM
Monday-Friday @ 1:30pm
Fresno, CA
WCNP 89.5 FM
Monday-Friday @ 8-8:30am
Reedsburg, Wisconsin

Recent

Video
Selling Jesus Part 2: Why Witnessing Isn't a Sales Pitch with Dr. R. Scott Clark
Rev. Chris Gordon and Dr. R. Scott Clark explain why Christian witness is not a sales pitch: believers pray for opportunities, speak honestly about Christ, and trust the Holy Spirit to work through the preached gospel.
Jesus Is the Rock
Moses was barred from the Promised Land not simply for striking the rock, but for meeting Israel's complaining with anger instead of holding out God's appointed remedy. The sermon shows that the answer to grumbling hearts is not law and wrath but Christ, the Rock who was struck for us.
Selling Jesus: Why Witnessing Isn't a Sales Pitch | Dr. R. Scott Clark
Dr. R. Scott Clark joins Rev. Chris Gordon to explain the difference between evangelism and witness, and why every Christian, not just pastors, can faithfully tell others the truth about Jesus.
Nothing But the Truth - 1 Kings 22
Today's sermon presses a single question: do we want what God has actually said, or what we think God should say?
Do vs. Done: The Law/Gospel Distinction with Dr. R. Scott Clark - Part 2
Rev. Chris Gordon and Dr. R. Scott Clark continue their conversation on the distinction between law and gospel, arguing that the issue is not only doctrine but tone. Preach the law in full force, they say, and then send burdened sinners to Christ without conditions.
Partakers of Grace - Phil 1
Paul's affection for the church at Philippi confronts the modern habit of treating the church as a product to consume. The believer's bond to a local congregation rests not on personal preference but on the shared grace of the gospel and the God who finishes what he begins.
Newsletter
Our newsletter is a great way to stay up-to-date with all our latest episodes, news, and content and helps us stay in close contact with our listeners.
Subscribe
Like, subscribe and share our podcast on your favorite platform. Be sure to follow us on social media and don't forget to join our newsletter!
Donate
Support The Abounding Grace Radio Ministry
The New Reformation Catechism On Human Sexuality
by Rev. Christopher Gordon

The New Reformation Catechism on Human Sexuality, authored by Rev. Christopher Gordon, is a new biblically based catechism giving clarity on critical issues concerning human sexuality.

"May God bless you richly as you grow in Christian liberty. May this book help you hold fast to the truth and better understand how the full counsel of God speaks to the godly priority of human sexuality."
~ Rosaria Butterfield
Visit Our Store